DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**softy54534** · 03-13-2009, 04:06 AM

Scale, no offence, but Andhimandhaarai is not an example of what Bala needs. Same with Pavithra's uyirum neeye - Bala is not about soulful etc. It is about dealing with negative emotions plumbing the depths of human mind which is what Bala does. There is a nice, 'moral', establishment view in Andhi Mandhaarai, Pavithra etc. Uyirum Neeye is not very far from Vennila, Vennila from Kaadhal Desam in terms of the emotion invoked. This is not an example of Rahman's ability to plumb the depths of human mind. This doesnt mean that he is not capable - just that there is no existing record of that fact.

Water is closer - thanks, I had forgotten that one. Fire was , how to say this without offending, very very superficial as a background score. So. yeah, if Bala says ARR is not capable of scoring for his movies, that is open to criticism but one can understand why Bala wouldnt want to make that choice.

I'd be glad if Bala is proven wrong on this one.

03-13-2009, 04:06 AM	#16
softy54534 Join Date Apr 2007 Posts 5,457 Senior Member	Scale, no offence, but Andhimandhaarai is not an example of what Bala needs. Same with Pavithra's uyirum neeye - Bala is not about soulful etc. It is about dealing with negative emotions plumbing the depths of human mind which is what Bala does. There is a nice, 'moral', establishment view in Andhi Mandhaarai, Pavithra etc. Uyirum Neeye is not very far from Vennila, Vennila from Kaadhal Desam in terms of the emotion invoked. This is not an example of Rahman's ability to plumb the depths of human mind. This doesnt mean that he is not capable - just that there is no existing record of that fact. Water is closer - thanks, I had forgotten that one. Fire was , how to say this without offending, very very superficial as a background score. So. yeah, if Bala says ARR is not capable of scoring for his movies, that is open to criticism but one can understand why Bala wouldnt want to make that choice. I'd be glad if Bala is proven wrong on this one.
	Quote