DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Evolution of Saivaism and it's development in Tamil Nadu

**Lt_Apple** · 11-03-2005, 04:44 AM

Purananuru -166 says

Nandru aintha NinimirSadai
Muthumuthalvan Vaipoka
Thondru Purintha Virirandin
Arunarntha Oru MuthuNool PURAM 166: 1-4

This is the reference to God Siva giving Vedas - Rig,Yajur, Sama and Athrva to Munivarkal and this is also confirmed by Tholkappiyam and Tirukural

Uppuma, you don't understand Sangam Tamil, do you! Why do you misinterpret the four lines. Why did you not post the lines in Tamil - afraid readers may know the meaning clearly? You are trying to mislead. Ok -The verse in Tamil Script,
¿ýÈ¡öó¾ ¿£û¿¢Á¢÷º¨¼
ÓÐÓ¾øÅý Å¡ö§À¡¸¡Ð,
´ýÚÒÃ¢ó¾ ®Ã¢ÃñÊý,
¬Ú½÷ó¾ ´ÕÓÐáø
Where is these lines are the names of the Four sanskritic vedas - the rig, sama, yajur and atharvan mentioned - as you claimed. The poet clearly talk about "oru muthu nool" - one ancient book. That exposed your lies - and stop your lies about Tholkappiyam and Thirukkural as well. Nothing of the vedas there!.

and I quote Kalithogai for easy reference.
Aru ari Anthanarku Arumarai Pala Pagarnthu Kali 1:1 So?? Where is Rig in here?

The ancient Tamil King was called PalYagasalai MuthuKudumi and on him the Sangam Song is

Velviyil Kadavul Aruththinai! Kelvi
Vuyarnilai Vulagathu Iyer Inpuruthinai!.... Pathrirrupattu 70:12,13. How ancient was the king? Any dates? Can YOu please explain the meaning of the Pathirrupathu Song.. Who is that 'velviyil kadavul'? The Third Sangam Period began after Tholkappiam - and contined till === When?? do you know, Mr Uppuma?

The Sangam Period overlapped the Bhakti period .. Some Sanga Pulavars lived after Thirungana Sambandar too. So?? If Sambandar talks of Velvi -- why shouldn't Sanga Pulavars - as a narration of what they witnessesed then!

Natpe, Every Objective Researcher who can really understand Tamil clearly confirms all this are referring to Vedas and even the name Sama Veda is named in one of the Sangam Songs

Hence let us ignore meaningless postings and constrate on what Sangam Lit. tells on evolution of Sivaniyam in Tamilnadu. There is very little religion you can extract from Sangam Literature - mostly heroic and love themes only. Keep trying but stop lying!

11-03-2005, 04:44 AM	#18
Lt_Apple Join Date Dec 2008 Posts 4,489 Senior Member	Purananuru -166 says Nandru aintha NinimirSadai Muthumuthalvan Vaipoka Thondru Purintha Virirandin Arunarntha Oru MuthuNool PURAM 166: 1-4 This is the reference to God Siva giving Vedas - Rig,Yajur, Sama and Athrva to Munivarkal and this is also confirmed by Tholkappiyam and Tirukural Uppuma, you don't understand Sangam Tamil, do you! Why do you misinterpret the four lines. Why did you not post the lines in Tamil - afraid readers may know the meaning clearly? You are trying to mislead. Ok -The verse in Tamil Script, ¿ýÈ¡öó¾ ¿£û¿¢Á¢÷º¨¼ ÓÐÓ¾øÅý Å¡ö§À¡¸¡Ð, ´ýÚÒÃ¢ó¾ ®Ã¢ÃñÊý, ¬Ú½÷ó¾ ´ÕÓÐáø Where is these lines are the names of the Four sanskritic vedas - the rig, sama, yajur and atharvan mentioned - as you claimed. The poet clearly talk about "oru muthu nool" - one ancient book. That exposed your lies - and stop your lies about Tholkappiyam and Thirukkural as well. Nothing of the vedas there!. and I quote Kalithogai for easy reference. Aru ari Anthanarku Arumarai Pala Pagarnthu Kali 1:1 So?? Where is Rig in here? The ancient Tamil King was called PalYagasalai MuthuKudumi and on him the Sangam Song is Velviyil Kadavul Aruththinai! Kelvi Vuyarnilai Vulagathu Iyer Inpuruthinai!.... Pathrirrupattu 70:12,13. How ancient was the king? Any dates? Can YOu please explain the meaning of the Pathirrupathu Song.. Who is that 'velviyil kadavul'? The Third Sangam Period began after Tholkappiam - and contined till === When?? do you know, Mr Uppuma? The Sangam Period overlapped the Bhakti period .. Some Sanga Pulavars lived after Thirungana Sambandar too. So?? If Sambandar talks of Velvi -- why shouldn't Sanga Pulavars - as a narration of what they witnessesed then! Natpe, Every Objective Researcher who can really understand Tamil clearly confirms all this are referring to Vedas and even the name Sama Veda is named in one of the Sangam Songs Hence let us ignore meaningless postings and constrate on what Sangam Lit. tells on evolution of Sivaniyam in Tamilnadu. There is very little religion you can extract from Sangam Literature - mostly heroic and love themes only. Keep trying but stop lying!
	Quote