DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Jyothisham

**Slonopotam845** · 04-27-2006, 05:26 AM

Originally Posted by kannannn r_kk, it is a waste of time to expect any rational answers for any of these claims. I can't keep count of the number of questions on which any scientific proofs have been forthcoming.

Saringa opicer.....

Srivatsan, I don't remember passing a curt comment on you before and I expect the same from you. r_kk's question is simple and clear. Quote a few shlokas or whatever and give your interpretation or show the connection between the celestial position of planets and moon and human destiny scientifically. Then I can accept your claim of astrology as a science. As for you thoughts on western science, I am reminded of the thread in the Miscellaneous section on why there are not many Indian inventions in the past few decades. Could our dogmatic attitudes be one of the reasons?

I cannot have r_kk as a reference point since r_kk's motion is random to me, but moon follows a constant path and I can predict its position with reference to any location on earth at any given time.

You are contradicting yourself. You say r_kk's motion is random and moon follows a predictable path. How can you then correlate moon's predictable path with r_kk's random actions?

04-27-2006, 05:26 AM	#34
Slonopotam845 Join Date Jan 2006 Posts 5,251 Senior Member	Originally Posted by kannannn r_kk, it is a waste of time to expect any rational answers for any of these claims. I can't keep count of the number of questions on which any scientific proofs have been forthcoming. Saringa opicer..... Srivatsan, I don't remember passing a curt comment on you before and I expect the same from you. r_kk's question is simple and clear. Quote a few shlokas or whatever and give your interpretation or show the connection between the celestial position of planets and moon and human destiny scientifically. Then I can accept your claim of astrology as a science. As for you thoughts on western science, I am reminded of the thread in the Miscellaneous section on why there are not many Indian inventions in the past few decades. Could our dogmatic attitudes be one of the reasons? I cannot have r_kk as a reference point since r_kk's motion is random to me, but moon follows a constant path and I can predict its position with reference to any location on earth at any given time. You are contradicting yourself. You say r_kk's motion is random and moon follows a predictable path. How can you then correlate moon's predictable path with r_kk's random actions?
	Quote