DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Jyothisham

**doctorzlo** · 04-27-2006, 06:48 AM

Please come to the point and reply to the simple question instead of asking what kind of science I believe or you believe, why I can't get answer to these simple questions etc etc. How do you correlate the celestial positions of planets and mythical object/phenomenon to day to day life of all creatures and non-life forms? Don't convert this discussion to individual level (what I believe or whether I make hasty conclusion just like that or not etc). Your statement on earthquake remembers me an astrologer who made big claims in other thread! Please come to the point. Tell me whether you have any kind of statistics or valid repeatable proofs to claim astrology as science. I had requested many people for so many years and failed to get any such proofs. In micellenous section here also, I requested a famous professional astrologer to give some proof long time back, but till now I haven't get any reply.
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...r=asc&start=27. If you can declare “Jyothitam as science” in the title of thread without any valid proofs, I also have the equal rights to start my comment as “pseudo science”

I dont hesitate to accept that I dont exactly know the link between planetary positions and human behaviour. I think this comes as an advanced stage of Jyothisha Shastra....For example, when we study how electricity makes a Fan to rotate or a bulb to glow ,in 4th standard or 5th Standard, we are not taught about the different atomoc models or electronic configuration stuff about electron movement....Similarly, in Jyothisha what many of us are taught or aware of is basic lessons & basic formulae.

What happens in reality is many around us, study this basic formulae and claim that they are astrologers and come out and starts predicting.....But the reason why I call it a science is simple....I am not a layman or a Eatern superiority person to claim whatever from Our country is better etc.,...but I have gone thru' the basics of Jyothisham, I am born and Brought up in a family who are quitre good at Jyothisham........and I know what type of extensive calculations are applied. By seeing this, I am able to understand and that there is really something solid when I go a further to the advance stage and that is what I am trying to do.

When I didn't understand Continuity eqyation when I was in my first year of B.E., I was able to feel and understand that there is something solid in the advanced version of this......I continued to study......and now I know what is the real meaning of Continuity equation.....Every subject needs time and practice to understand Research to reach the adanced stage.........and this applied to Jyothisham as well. Researches are already made several 1000 years ago and unfortuanately they are not documented or we are not equipped to understand the Documentation.....The only way to reach the advance stage is.......either to wait pateintly till you undertand it by yourself or to study the available document and try to comprehend the rest........not critisizing at the very forst step when you dont understand the subject........I dont evade, If you think, you want to learn something, you will learn only by putting effort on it, not by throwing questions......or critisizing....!

Prediction is a part of Atrlogy...It is Not the whole Astrology...

04-27-2006, 06:48 AM	#36
doctorzlo Join Date Jun 2006 Posts 4,488 Senior Member	Please come to the point and reply to the simple question instead of asking what kind of science I believe or you believe, why I can't get answer to these simple questions etc etc. How do you correlate the celestial positions of planets and mythical object/phenomenon to day to day life of all creatures and non-life forms? Don't convert this discussion to individual level (what I believe or whether I make hasty conclusion just like that or not etc). Your statement on earthquake remembers me an astrologer who made big claims in other thread! Please come to the point. Tell me whether you have any kind of statistics or valid repeatable proofs to claim astrology as science. I had requested many people for so many years and failed to get any such proofs. In micellenous section here also, I requested a famous professional astrologer to give some proof long time back, but till now I haven't get any reply. http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...r=asc&start=27. If you can declare “Jyothitam as science” in the title of thread without any valid proofs, I also have the equal rights to start my comment as “pseudo science” I dont hesitate to accept that I dont exactly know the link between planetary positions and human behaviour. I think this comes as an advanced stage of Jyothisha Shastra....For example, when we study how electricity makes a Fan to rotate or a bulb to glow ,in 4th standard or 5th Standard, we are not taught about the different atomoc models or electronic configuration stuff about electron movement....Similarly, in Jyothisha what many of us are taught or aware of is basic lessons & basic formulae. What happens in reality is many around us, study this basic formulae and claim that they are astrologers and come out and starts predicting.....But the reason why I call it a science is simple....I am not a layman or a Eatern superiority person to claim whatever from Our country is better etc.,...but I have gone thru' the basics of Jyothisham, I am born and Brought up in a family who are quitre good at Jyothisham........and I know what type of extensive calculations are applied. By seeing this, I am able to understand and that there is really something solid when I go a further to the advance stage and that is what I am trying to do. When I didn't understand Continuity eqyation when I was in my first year of B.E., I was able to feel and understand that there is something solid in the advanced version of this......I continued to study......and now I know what is the real meaning of Continuity equation.....Every subject needs time and practice to understand Research to reach the adanced stage.........and this applied to Jyothisham as well. Researches are already made several 1000 years ago and unfortuanately they are not documented or we are not equipped to understand the Documentation.....The only way to reach the advance stage is.......either to wait pateintly till you undertand it by yourself or to study the available document and try to comprehend the rest........not critisizing at the very forst step when you dont understand the subject........I dont evade, If you think, you want to learn something, you will learn only by putting effort on it, not by throwing questions......or critisizing....! Prediction is a part of Atrlogy...It is Not the whole Astrology...
	Quote