DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Historical Novels: Ponniyin Selvan vs Kadal Pura

**Big A** · 12-09-2005, 08:00 AM

Topic started by AK (@ sgigate.sgi.com) on Wed Nov 7 04:10:16 .

Hi,

I just finished "Kadal Pura" by Sandilyan and wanted to get some views on what others think of it. Someone on this forum recommended Kadal Pura as a great historical novel. I think I would have to disagree.

A historical novel is one which not only is set in historical times but also is built upon a series of historical events. Moreover, it also ought to comment upon the social melieu of those times. Sadly, Kadal pura was a huge disappointment in those terms. Although, the setting was historical and a couple of main characters were, almost none of the events had any historical basis.

It almost seemed at times like it was a Rajnikanth movie with its larger than life hero Karunakara Pallavan doing amazing deeds.

Ponniyin Selvan on the other hand was a joy to read. It discussed the political/social situation in the country... discussed the historical aspects.. with a lot of vivid imagination thrown in to boot.

I would love to hear comments from other people who have read both the books.

Cheers,

AK

12-09-2005, 08:00 AM	#13
Big A Join Date Oct 2005 Age 50 Posts 4,148 Administrator	Historical Novels: Ponniyin Selvan vs Kadal Pura Topic started by AK (@ sgigate.sgi.com) on Wed Nov 7 04:10:16 . Hi, I just finished "Kadal Pura" by Sandilyan and wanted to get some views on what others think of it. Someone on this forum recommended Kadal Pura as a great historical novel. I think I would have to disagree. A historical novel is one which not only is set in historical times but also is built upon a series of historical events. Moreover, it also ought to comment upon the social melieu of those times. Sadly, Kadal pura was a huge disappointment in those terms. Although, the setting was historical and a couple of main characters were, almost none of the events had any historical basis. It almost seemed at times like it was a Rajnikanth movie with its larger than life hero Karunakara Pallavan doing amazing deeds. Ponniyin Selvan on the other hand was a joy to read. It discussed the political/social situation in the country... discussed the historical aspects.. with a lot of vivid imagination thrown in to boot. I would love to hear comments from other people who have read both the books. Cheers, AK
	Quote