[Peptobismol]

i cant belive that why didnt you guys understand the difference between a movie being commercial hit and a movie being musical hit.Most of Harris jayaraj movies are comercially big hits but not all of them are musical hits, but half of Yuvans movies did badly at BO but musical hits.

Whenever HJ worked with big shots like Goutham, Shankar and Murugadaas the songs became big hits, this would happen regardless of any MD's.Even Anniyan and Saamy songs didnt received well by fans initially , once the movie became big hit, the songs were also started to do well.On the other hand even though the songs of the movie Leysa Leysa are really good (only one of my HJ favourite other than Minnale) but it wasnt a musical when compared with HJ's other hit, 'cos movie is not commercial hit.

But when you look at the movies he did with not so big shots like Hari and others (Kovil, Majnu,Arul, Arashatchi,samurai etc) he failed miserably musicwise and movies were also flops.this is where Yuvan score better than HJ , even though almost all of his movies are not with bigshots (apart from Vasanth and lingusamy i guess) but 80% of them are musical hits.

The bottom line is in 2004 and 2005 Yuvan gave commercial hits like manmathan, raam, AA and pattiyal back to back so he was hyped by media as No 1 MD and so and so. but in 2005 and 2006 HJ gave big hits like Gajini and VV back to back so he has been celebrated by media , cinema people and fans right now.But when you compare Yuvan and HJ in Quality, innovation, trend setting music, BGM Youvan scores over HJ comportably.