DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**doctorzlo** · 07-12-2006, 07:27 AM

Not sure whether you are aware of the follg songs & none of them have relation to the main tune :

Sivandha mann – Oru raja raniyidam
Kadhalikka neramillai – Naalaam naalam thirunaalam
Ooty varai uravu - Thedinen vandhadhu
Parakkum paavai - Kalayana naal paarka
Deiva thaai – Oru pennai paarthu nilavai paarthen
Engal thangam – Thanga padhakathin mele
Vaazkai padagu – Aayiram penmai malaruttme
Enga veetu pillai – Kangalum kaavadi sindhadattum
Avargal – Kaatrukenna veli ( don’t say that this came after IR’s arrival ! )
Pasam – Ulagam pirandhadhu enakaaga
Ulagam suttrum vaaliban – Thanga thoniyile & Lilli malarukku
Nadodee – Thirumi vaa oliye thirumbi vaa

The above songs infact have a lengthy preludes & they are in no way linked to main song but sync beautifully !

It’s a big list. I have just given few examples to you so that you may get enlightened

By the way, I am a woman….. So Ms only pls !

Besides, I too love IR music but no comparisons with MSV pls

Ms.Billgates

Fine I remember every tune of the song you have mentioned here and have listened to them umpteen times. But the preludes never got registered in my mind [except the Aaaaa.... for Katrukkenna Veli]

hence i should have slipped in telling MSV's song dont have a different prelude. IMO MSV's songs were more popular for their simple yet beautiful tunes and that is why they get registered well while he dont give much importance to the preludes and interludes.
On the other end IR used to give us richly orchestrated songs with beautiful preludes and interludes, which gets registered well in our minds.that is why when i sing [ a bathroom singer ofcourse ] his songs, i start right from humming the prelude move on to the song, then, hum the interludes, and then, finish of the song.
This is not my individual experience it happens to many, i have noticed who tries singing an IR song. If not why then there are many articles and posts right here in TFM page discussing the preludes and interludes of Raja. Infact the Forum even conducted a contest on 'Ludes of Raja'.
This post is not to demean MSV in any way. It is a thought i have that IR gave new dimensions and colors to the preludes and interludes in his songs and MSV was very good at coming up with nice tunes. That is why when they worked together MSV was assigned to set the tune while IR was assigned to Orchestrate

[/tscii]

07-12-2006, 07:27 AM	#6
doctorzlo Join Date Jun 2006 Posts 4,488 Senior Member	Not sure whether you are aware of the follg songs & none of them have relation to the main tune : Sivandha mann – Oru raja raniyidam Kadhalikka neramillai – Naalaam naalam thirunaalam Ooty varai uravu - Thedinen vandhadhu Parakkum paavai - Kalayana naal paarka Deiva thaai – Oru pennai paarthu nilavai paarthen Engal thangam – Thanga padhakathin mele Vaazkai padagu – Aayiram penmai malaruttme Enga veetu pillai – Kangalum kaavadi sindhadattum Avargal – Kaatrukenna veli ( don’t say that this came after IR’s arrival ! ) Pasam – Ulagam pirandhadhu enakaaga Ulagam suttrum vaaliban – Thanga thoniyile & Lilli malarukku Nadodee – Thirumi vaa oliye thirumbi vaa The above songs infact have a lengthy preludes & they are in no way linked to main song but sync beautifully ! It’s a big list. I have just given few examples to you so that you may get enlightened By the way, I am a woman….. So Ms only pls ! Besides, I too love IR music but no comparisons with MSV pls Ms.Billgates Fine I remember every tune of the song you have mentioned here and have listened to them umpteen times. But the preludes never got registered in my mind [except the Aaaaa.... for Katrukkenna Veli] hence i should have slipped in telling MSV's song dont have a different prelude. IMO MSV's songs were more popular for their simple yet beautiful tunes and that is why they get registered well while he dont give much importance to the preludes and interludes. On the other end IR used to give us richly orchestrated songs with beautiful preludes and interludes, which gets registered well in our minds.that is why when i sing [ a bathroom singer ofcourse ] his songs, i start right from humming the prelude move on to the song, then, hum the interludes, and then, finish of the song. This is not my individual experience it happens to many, i have noticed who tries singing an IR song. If not why then there are many articles and posts right here in TFM page discussing the preludes and interludes of Raja. Infact the Forum even conducted a contest on 'Ludes of Raja'. This post is not to demean MSV in any way. It is a thought i have that IR gave new dimensions and colors to the preludes and interludes in his songs and MSV was very good at coming up with nice tunes. That is why when they worked together MSV was assigned to set the tune while IR was assigned to Orchestrate [/tscii]
	Quote