DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**HedgeYourBets** · 12-24-2005, 05:07 PM

Pavan dear,
I want YSR to go natl/intl and hit bigtime,but i repeat 'not doing senseless' projects,u need example? prefabricated plasticky mess like DIL SE,YUVA,KABHI NA KABHI,Irs MAHADEV... Dear Mr.kalladicrapp
U mean to say that YSR would've rejected these subjects had he been in ARR's place. Give me a break! C'mon, during a time when it was hard for any south indians to be recognised in the Hindi film arena, it was ARR who showed the way with hits in hindi films and today even if YSR does any hindi film he should thank ARR for that. Dilse is certainly not a hit , but the music was such a massive hit that attracted a wide variety of audiences over the world.

I never meant an insult to ARR,I simply dislike him for he killed the rustic flavour,the tamil identity of a school of music that was so unique. What is it that YSR has done to regain the identity of school of music that was so unique that was killed by ARR? Songs like "Pushing it hard", "Baby Baby", Killing the songs in the name of Remixes? Why cant he do the music of PP over here with the help of tamil school of music instead of using Bangkok school of music? See, If u r to be recognised in the Intl' arena u have to break certain barriers and that's what ARR has exactly done which has really paid dividends and I'm sure YSR will also follow the same path.

Talking about risk,the music of PP itself is a big risk when songs from Sivakasi or Chandramukhi rule the charts.The whole effort,so much attention on the musical aspect of a commercial potboiler should be given its due,especially coming from such a young person.ARR or IR or MSV i bet never strained for such results when they were 23. C'mon imagine the kind of risk ARR has taken by accepting films like Tehzeeb, LOBS, Zubeidaa, Swades, Bose, MAngal Pnadey... Would any MD dare to accept these kind of films in a row when he is at the peak?

PP is a very good effort. YSR is best MD next to ARR , accepted. But dont tell that he is doing what ARR hasn't done. He is following ARR's path and in future everyone will follow ARR.

12-24-2005, 05:07 PM	#18
HedgeYourBets Join Date Aug 2008 Posts 4,655 Senior Member	Pavan dear, I want YSR to go natl/intl and hit bigtime,but i repeat 'not doing senseless' projects,u need example? prefabricated plasticky mess like DIL SE,YUVA,KABHI NA KABHI,Irs MAHADEV... Dear Mr.kalladicrapp U mean to say that YSR would've rejected these subjects had he been in ARR's place. Give me a break! C'mon, during a time when it was hard for any south indians to be recognised in the Hindi film arena, it was ARR who showed the way with hits in hindi films and today even if YSR does any hindi film he should thank ARR for that. Dilse is certainly not a hit , but the music was such a massive hit that attracted a wide variety of audiences over the world. I never meant an insult to ARR,I simply dislike him for he killed the rustic flavour,the tamil identity of a school of music that was so unique. What is it that YSR has done to regain the identity of school of music that was so unique that was killed by ARR? Songs like "Pushing it hard", "Baby Baby", Killing the songs in the name of Remixes? Why cant he do the music of PP over here with the help of tamil school of music instead of using Bangkok school of music? See, If u r to be recognised in the Intl' arena u have to break certain barriers and that's what ARR has exactly done which has really paid dividends and I'm sure YSR will also follow the same path. Talking about risk,the music of PP itself is a big risk when songs from Sivakasi or Chandramukhi rule the charts.The whole effort,so much attention on the musical aspect of a commercial potboiler should be given its due,especially coming from such a young person.ARR or IR or MSV i bet never strained for such results when they were 23. C'mon imagine the kind of risk ARR has taken by accepting films like Tehzeeb, LOBS, Zubeidaa, Swades, Bose, MAngal Pnadey... Would any MD dare to accept these kind of films in a row when he is at the peak? PP is a very good effort. YSR is best MD next to ARR , accepted. But dont tell that he is doing what ARR hasn't done. He is following ARR's path and in future everyone will follow ARR.
	Quote