DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**NeroASERCH** · 03-09-2006, 03:54 PM

whtz a good comparision.. i dont know whtz not good with PP
though ManiRatnam was not intrested in songs for YUVA .. ARR forced him to keep songs to retain the reputation.. on the otherhand which yuvan tried out with confidence of coming up with an unique album..with OSTs . for a young kido in TFM itz really a brave attempt..I cant say whether he will reach the heights of IR or ARR.. But I am sure he got a bright future in TFM only time can answer

Then what stopped him from going without any songs? THe same reputation. THe point I was trying to make is KK was better than Thulluvadhi Ilamai, 7G was better than KK. Naturally one would expect PP to better 7G, but sadly that dint happen. U may claim that its an unique album etc... but the point is songs wise 7G was better. The songs in this movie are not something which would lift the movie. It is the otherway, if the film becomes a hit the songs will be a hit and if the film flops the songs may even go unnoticed.

03-09-2006, 03:54 PM	#34
NeroASERCH Join Date Jul 2006 Posts 5,147 Senior Member	whtz a good comparision.. i dont know whtz not good with PP though ManiRatnam was not intrested in songs for YUVA .. ARR forced him to keep songs to retain the reputation.. on the otherhand which yuvan tried out with confidence of coming up with an unique album..with OSTs . for a young kido in TFM itz really a brave attempt..I cant say whether he will reach the heights of IR or ARR.. But I am sure he got a bright future in TFM only time can answer Then what stopped him from going without any songs? THe same reputation. THe point I was trying to make is KK was better than Thulluvadhi Ilamai, 7G was better than KK. Naturally one would expect PP to better 7G, but sadly that dint happen. U may claim that its an unique album etc... but the point is songs wise 7G was better. The songs in this movie are not something which would lift the movie. It is the otherway, if the film becomes a hit the songs will be a hit and if the film flops the songs may even go unnoticed.
	Quote