Thread
:
Dynamic Drake equation page
View Single Post
08-31-2012, 05:02 PM
#
15
Kamepherype
Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
461
Senior Member
If I were rewriting the DE I would break up Fi x Fc differently.
I would have a (Fraction of planets with life that develop complex, multicellular animal life). It seems to me that this is an important, non-trivial step, and at least potentially could be treated in a semi-rigorous factor. It would describe factors like the length of time that a planets surface remains tectonically active (if you hold to the importance of that, as described by Ward & Brownlee).
I'd also be tempted to then just combine the remaining (Fraction of planets with complex, multicellular animal life that develop intelligent life) and Fc into a single number. It's always bothered me that "intelligent life" is a somewhat arbitrary cutoff for a species, and "radio telescopes" is a somewhat arbitrary cutoff for a culture, so I don't see why you need two arbitrary points just to mark some nature/culture divide. That's a rather secondary issue though.
Quote
Kamepherype
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Kamepherype
All times are GMT +1. The time now is
02:31 PM
.