even if one believes in kamma and rebirth, unless one is enlightened, one cannot necessary know one's past deeds and there is no reason to speculate on it.
But my question for you two, or others is, then is what is your personal goal for practicing Buddhism? Let us say that a person is enlightened, and then he dies and then he is no more. Then what? Is there a point for that person to reach enlightenment, whatever your definition of enlightenment is?