DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The Questions of King Milinda and rebirth

**Hmwmzian** · 11-01-2011, 08:08 PM

He gives similes about how rebirth can happen without transmigration

Hi FBM,
It makes perfect sense to me. I would say that what we are discussing forms the basis for Buddha's direct insight into anatta. Where is the atta or self within the 12 links? nowhere to be found. Buddha must have seen this when recalling past abidings. The process unfolds of itself without the necessity of a 'being' to jump from life to life.

As to the process itself I have encountered two different takes; the first that it is a kind of linear event with craving, ignorance etc. at its root. The second that it is simultaneously and dualistically dependent-arisen. The two do not contradict each other in my opinion, yet I tend to incline to the latter as it more completely resolves the issue for me.

Namaste
Kris

11-01-2011, 08:08 PM	#12
Hmwmzian Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 495 Senior Member	He gives similes about how rebirth can happen without transmigration Hi FBM, It makes perfect sense to me. I would say that what we are discussing forms the basis for Buddha's direct insight into anatta. Where is the atta or self within the 12 links? nowhere to be found. Buddha must have seen this when recalling past abidings. The process unfolds of itself without the necessity of a 'being' to jump from life to life. As to the process itself I have encountered two different takes; the first that it is a kind of linear event with craving, ignorance etc. at its root. The second that it is simultaneously and dualistically dependent-arisen. The two do not contradict each other in my opinion, yet I tend to incline to the latter as it more completely resolves the issue for me. Namaste Kris
	Quote