Thread
:
Has Anyone Watched "Michael and Me?" (Rebuttal to Bowling for Columbine)
View Single Post
12-14-2005, 05:22 AM
#
13
Quonuttott
Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
434
Senior Member
Firearm Safety In
America 2005
The number of privately owned guns in the U.S. is at an all-time high, and rises by
about 4.5 million per year.1 Meanwhile, the nation's violent crime rate has decreased every year since 1991 and is
now at a 27-year low.2 Below, statistics from 1981 forward are from the National Center for Health Statistics,3
while those prior to 1981 are from the National Safety Council.4 The NCHS' annual numbers, rates, and trends of
common accidents and selected other causes of death, for the U.S., each state, and the District of Columbia, are
available on the NRA-ILA website in spreadsheet format.5
Firearm accident deaths have been decreasing
for decades. Since 1930, their annual number has decreased 76%, while the U.S. population has more than doubled and
the number of firearms has quintupled. Among children, such deaths have decreased 89% since 1975.
Firearm
accident deaths are at an all-time annual low, nationally and among children, while the U.S. population is at an
all-time high. In 2002, there were 762 such deaths nationally, including 60 among children. Today, the odds are more
than a million to one against a child in the U.S. dying from a firearm accident.
The firearm accident death rate
is at an all-time annual low, 0.26 per 100,000 population, down 92% since the all-time high in 1904.
Firearms
are involved in 1% of all deaths, and 1% of all deaths among children. Deaths involving firearms have decreased 19%
since 1993.
Firearms are involved in 0.7% of accidental deaths nationally, and in 1% among children. Most
accidental deaths involve, or are due to, motor vehicles (41%), poisoning (16%), falls (15%), suffocation (5%),
drowning (3%), fires (3%), medical mistakes (2%), environmental factors (1%), and bicycles (1%). Among children:
motor vehicles (44%), suffocation (16%), drowning (16%), fires (9%), bicycles (2%), poisoning (2%), falls (2%),
environmental factors (1%), and medical mistakes (1%).
Education decreases accidents. Voluntary firearms
safety training, not government intrusion, has decreased firearms accidents. NRA firearm safety programs are
conducted by 62,000 NRA Certified Instructors and Coaches nationwide. Youngsters learn firearm safety in NRA
programs offered through civic groups such as the Boy Scouts, Jaycees, the American Legion, and schools.6 NRA's
Eddie Eagle GunSafe(r) program teaches children pre-K through 6th grade that if they see a firearm without
supervision, they should "STOP! Don't Touch. Leave The Area. Tell An Adult." Since 1988, the program has been used
by more than 22,000 schools, civic groups, and law enforcement agencies to reach 18 million children.7
The "cars
and guns" myth. "Gun control" supporters advocate government intrusion, rather than education, to reduce accidents.
They claim that driver licensing and auto registration caused motor vehicle accident deaths to decline between
1968-1991, and that gun registration and gun owner licensing would reduce gun accidents. They ask, "We register
drivers and license cars, so why not guns and gun owners?"
Actually, vehicle registration and driver licensing
laws were not imposed to reduce accidents, nor did the increased regulation reduce accidents. Most vehicle
registration and driver licensing laws were imposed between the world wars, but motor vehicle accident deaths
increased sharply after 1930 and didn't begin declining until 1970. And despite more regulation of vehicles and
drivers over the years, vehicle accident deaths have increased during the last decade.
Between 1968-1991, the
years cited by the anti-gunners, the motor vehicle accident death rate dropped only 37% with vehicle registration
and driver licensing, while the firearm accident death rate dropped 50% without gun registration and gun owner
licensing. The truth is, the anti-gunners want registration and licensing not for safety, but to erect the
record-keeping apparatus necessary to make confiscation of privately owned firearms achievable in the future. The
first leader of Handgun Control, Inc. (since renamed the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence) said that
registration was the second step in the group's three-step plan to confiscate all handguns.8
Another difference
between guns and cars is that the purchase and ownership of arms is a right expressly protected by the constitution,
whereas operating a vehicle on public roads is a privilege. A license and registration are not required to merely
own a vehicle or operate it on private property, only to do so on public roads. Similarly, a license and permit are
not typically required to buy or own a gun, or to keep a gun at home, but are usually required when hunting or
carrying a gun for protection in public places.
Anti-gunners' lies about children and guns. Brady Campaign
president, Michael Barnes, and Senator Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.) claimed that 12 children die from gun accidents every
day. President Bill Clinton campaigned for so called "triggerlock" and "smart" gun laws, claiming that 13 children
are killed with guns every day. Possible 2008 presidential candidate Hillary Clinton claimed, "Every day in America
we lose 13 precious children to gun-related violence." The HELP Network put the figure at "an average of 9 children"
daily. Other "gun control" advocates have varyingly claimed 14 per day (or 5,000 yearly or one every 90 seconds).
Some count anyone under the age of 24 as a "child," to get even higher numbers.9 In fact, on average there is one
firearm-related death among children per day, including one accidental death every six days. Anti-gunners add the
relatively small number of firearm related deaths among children to the much larger number of deaths among juveniles
and young adults, and dishonestly call the total "children."
"Gun control" supporters point to a study claiming
that so-called "Child Access Prevention" (CAP) laws (which make it a crime, under some circumstances, to leave a gun
accessible to a child who obtains and misuses it), imposed in 12 states between 1989-1993, decreased fatal firearm
accidents among children.10 The study was produced by people from the Harborview Injury Prevention and Research
Center, a group active in the HELP (Handgun Epidemic Lowering Plan) Network, which is dedicated to "changing
society's attitude toward guns so that it becomes socially unacceptable for private citizens to have handguns." The
study's flaws: Firearm accident deaths among children began declining in the mid-1970s, not in 1989, when "CAP"
laws were first imposed. Also, such accidents have decreased nationwide, not only in "CAP" states. And, also in
1989, NRA's Eddie Eagle GunSafe Program(r) was introduced nationwide.
1. See BATF, "Firearms Commerce in the
United States 2001/2002" (
www.atf.gov/pub/index.htm#Firearms)
.
2. FBI, Crime in the United States 2003
(
www.fbi.gov/ucr/ucr.htm#cius)
, BJS (
http://bjsdata.ojp.usdoj.gov/dataonline/)
, and FBI
(
http://www.fbi.gov/pressrel/pressrel...srel121304.htm
and
www.fbi.gov/ucr/2004/6mosprelim04.pdf)
.
3. See
www.cdc.gov/ncipc/wisqars
or
wonder.cdc.gov.
4. Available at
www.nsc.org/
.
5. See
http://www.nraila.org/Issues/FactShe...ad.aspx?ID=127
.
6. For more on NRA training programs, visit
www.nrahq.org
(click "Education and Training") or call 703-267-1500.
7. For more on the Eddie Eagle
program, visit
www.nrahq.org/safety/eddie/
or call 703-267-1573.
8. Pete Shields, quoted in The New
Yorker, "A Reporter At Large: Handguns," July 26, 1976.
9. NRA-ILA "Not 12 Per Day" fact sheet,
http://www.nraila.org/Issues/FactSheets/Read.aspx?ID=21
10. Journal of the American Medical
Association, Oct. 1, 1997.
Posted: 1/21/2005
Quote
Quonuttott
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Quonuttott
All times are GMT +1. The time now is
05:06 PM
.