DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**xquFzpNw** · 09-14-2011, 09:29 PM

It depends on what is deemed as picking and choosing. One is where one literally picks and chooses everyday to do the same action differently.
the other is where you pick a opinion and then stick to it. so if you decide you want to pray salah as a shafi'i,then you adopt that method along with its rulings everyday and not,when one day you start bleeding, you suddenly say i'll take ruling of the shafi'i school.........to get out of this fix due to not being able to be bothered to repeat wudhu. Ive read a article by a erudite scholar who stated it was normal for people of the past to pray salah as a hanafi yet adopt another madhab for a another part of deen,like say zakaah etc. Its not as abnormal as its being made out.

09-14-2011, 09:29 PM	#7
xquFzpNw Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 501 Senior Member	It depends on what is deemed as picking and choosing. One is where one literally picks and chooses everyday to do the same action differently. the other is where you pick a opinion and then stick to it. so if you decide you want to pray salah as a shafi'i,then you adopt that method along with its rulings everyday and not,when one day you start bleeding, you suddenly say i'll take ruling of the shafi'i school.........to get out of this fix due to not being able to be bothered to repeat wudhu. Ive read a article by a erudite scholar who stated it was normal for people of the past to pray salah as a hanafi yet adopt another madhab for a another part of deen,like say zakaah etc. Its not as abnormal as its being made out.
	Quote