DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**9rCR9hWL** · 03-03-2012, 09:57 AM

There are two views in the madhab on a man removing his beard: 1) haram and 2) makruh.

If you know Arabic I can give you a host of quotes to support this.

So according to what U wrote, it is either haram or makruh, right? NOTHING ELSE.

Let's use an example:

Hydrogen Cyanide kills within 1 hour, bi iznillah

Gaseous Chlorine may take longer, bi iznillah.

Are you now going to argue about the duration of time it takes before a person dies???

Isn't it the same thing over with the beard thing - it's either makruh or Haram!

Btw tell us one thing Shaykh Isa, what is the ruling of doing a makruh act in the shaf'i madhdhab?

03-03-2012, 09:57 AM	#5
9rCR9hWL Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 382 Senior Member	There are two views in the madhab on a man removing his beard: 1) haram and 2) makruh. If you know Arabic I can give you a host of quotes to support this. So according to what U wrote, it is either haram or makruh, right? NOTHING ELSE. Let's use an example: Hydrogen Cyanide kills within 1 hour, bi iznillah Gaseous Chlorine may take longer, bi iznillah. Are you now going to argue about the duration of time it takes before a person dies??? Isn't it the same thing over with the beard thing - it's either makruh or Haram! Btw tell us one thing Shaykh Isa, what is the ruling of doing a makruh act in the shaf'i madhdhab?
	Quote