DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Tori Amos Confessions: Unforumzed Edition

**Meenepek** · 07-25-2012, 02:48 AM

I think Mac Aladdin's guitar work on Scarlet's Walk is actually quite good.

Me, too. I was listening to both this album and TBK not too long ago and noticed that. I think if he just stuck to acoustic, it'd be alright.

Confession: Looking at Tori's 2012 face, I don't find her 2005 face bizarre anymore.

, so true. I can look at TBK era photos and almost think she didn't have anything done at that point.

Mine:

I enjoy American Doll Posse much more than Scarlet's Walk (in fact ADP is my favorite post-SLG record). I know the songwriting is better on the latter, but the production just makes it a snoozefest for me to listen to. ADP certainly has it's drawbacks, but the good songs are pretty good and the whole thing has some energy.
I think the songs on Scarlet's Hidden Treasures are better than 2/3 of what's on Scarlet's Walk.

07-25-2012, 02:48 AM	#14
Meenepek Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 500 Senior Member	I think Mac Aladdin's guitar work on Scarlet's Walk is actually quite good. Me, too. I was listening to both this album and TBK not too long ago and noticed that. I think if he just stuck to acoustic, it'd be alright. Confession: Looking at Tori's 2012 face, I don't find her 2005 face bizarre anymore. , so true. I can look at TBK era photos and almost think she didn't have anything done at that point. Mine: I enjoy American Doll Posse much more than Scarlet's Walk (in fact ADP is my favorite post-SLG record). I know the songwriting is better on the latter, but the production just makes it a snoozefest for me to listen to. ADP certainly has it's drawbacks, but the good songs are pretty good and the whole thing has some energy. I think the songs on Scarlet's Hidden Treasures are better than 2/3 of what's on Scarlet's Walk.
	Quote