DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**WoCTrt0X** · 02-07-2010, 08:01 AM

the other main problem is whether or not she has the original mixes that appeared on the singles. The version of Take to the Sky we got on A Piano was an alternate mix but was not labeled as such on the tracklisting.

the other thing is how Fade To Red had all the TOAL mixes on it...at first I thought it was her being all crazy and liking those versions better but now I think she doesn't have the original tapes or that they are damaged.

but then I think she's talked out of her ass when I see tracks like Girl and Honey being simply remastered with no harm done(considering all LE were there easily on disc A with her just choosing the Crucify remix instead of the album version). and I wonder if these alternate mixes (which were respective to their era) were used so she could make the set seem like it had more unreleased material on it...(but then why not use the b-sides?) Could a full b-sides set be called A Piano? I think the 2006 deal with Rhino was for just Video collection and just a generic anthology compilation (which is why didn't get a B-Sides set weren't no matter what.)

I do love this set a lot actually and to me it's her best release since scarlet up to this day for me anyway.

02-07-2010, 08:01 AM	#8
WoCTrt0X Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 498 Senior Member	the other main problem is whether or not she has the original mixes that appeared on the singles. The version of Take to the Sky we got on A Piano was an alternate mix but was not labeled as such on the tracklisting. the other thing is how Fade To Red had all the TOAL mixes on it...at first I thought it was her being all crazy and liking those versions better but now I think she doesn't have the original tapes or that they are damaged. but then I think she's talked out of her ass when I see tracks like Girl and Honey being simply remastered with no harm done(considering all LE were there easily on disc A with her just choosing the Crucify remix instead of the album version). and I wonder if these alternate mixes (which were respective to their era) were used so she could make the set seem like it had more unreleased material on it...(but then why not use the b-sides?) Could a full b-sides set be called A Piano? I think the 2006 deal with Rhino was for just Video collection and just a generic anthology compilation (which is why didn't get a B-Sides set weren't no matter what.) I do love this set a lot actually and to me it's her best release since scarlet up to this day for me anyway.
	Quote