DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**tsovimnpb** · 10-15-2007, 07:32 PM

Ok now you have stipulated it a bit more I see your point. In either case, right now not factoring in future development I would take (and presuming all are in good health):

Regardless of team:
Brady
Manning
Romo
Hasselback
Carson Palmer

On the right team:
McNabb
Rothlesburger
Drew Brees

I don't deny how good favre is (was) but I don't feel like he's a top 5, and is maybe a top 10 qb today...

That maybe true, but you can't deny that when Favre steps on the field, the Packers have the chance to win against anyone. Can you truly say that about Romo, Hasselbeck and Palmer? Maybe I'm just spoiled with having Favre for so long, but I can't say that about those three guys. Manning and Brady, without a doubt.

10-15-2007, 07:32 PM	#92
tsovimnpb Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 529 Senior Member	Ok now you have stipulated it a bit more I see your point. In either case, right now not factoring in future development I would take (and presuming all are in good health): Regardless of team: Brady Manning Romo Hasselback Carson Palmer On the right team: McNabb Rothlesburger Drew Brees I don't deny how good favre is (was) but I don't feel like he's a top 5, and is maybe a top 10 qb today... That maybe true, but you can't deny that when Favre steps on the field, the Packers have the chance to win against anyone. Can you truly say that about Romo, Hasselbeck and Palmer? Maybe I'm just spoiled with having Favre for so long, but I can't say that about those three guys. Manning and Brady, without a doubt.
	Quote