Ok now you have stipulated it a bit more I see your point. In either case, right now not factoring in future development I would take (and presuming all are in good health): Regardless of team: Brady Manning Romo Hasselback Carson Palmer On the right team: McNabb Rothlesburger Drew Brees I don't deny how good favre is (was) but I don't feel like he's a top 5, and is maybe a top 10 qb today...