He is so ridiculously overhyped by the New York and nationwide media it isn't even funny. That one play he made this year, where he went crashing into the stands... not too many other shortstops go crashing into the stands, because most of them are camped under the ball. If Derek Jeter played in Minnesota, no one would even consider him to be one of the best shortstops in the game. But he's the captain of the Yankees, and he's been hyped into a first ballot Hall of Famer.