Holy cow, these "hcg shakes" have as much or more carbs than protein! Here's a comparison of a few different protein shakes that were recommended by other hcg'ers. I haven't tried any of them yet - I wanted to compare them first. I also compared just the chocolate versions of these shakes so I could get a good apples-to-apples comparison. Protein Powders.jpg Click the thumbnail for an enlarged image.