Matt, iamwhatiseem, I agree with you both. Guns is not the issue. Human life is the issue and that trumps even the Constitution.
Forgive me if I take this issue too personally. I went to NO after the tragedy. I looked into the faces of the victims and I heard their stories. I looked into the face of a 14 year-old boy who couldn't find his parents. I talked to a minister who was overwhelmed by people seeking his help and watched him start to cry as he spoke of his shame that he couldn't do more for them. I watched a woman who had lost her baby and the blank stare on her face has been blazed into my memory for the rest of my life.
Personally, I'm shocked at the apathy of the American people for their own fellow citizens in this so-called "god-fearing" land. Can't tell me shit about God and believers. Those who took up the mantle of responsibility for their fellow citizens were spiritual, not religious, not gun-lovers .. and it is in they who I place my faith in Americans.
If you both believe that Nagin's act was an affront to the Constitution and "freedom" .. then more power to you my brothers.