Everyone involved sounds like a fucking idiot, to be honest. Some idiot gives another idiot his unfixed dog and allows it to be bred with another idiot's dog. Then all of the idiots get into a big argument over one of NINE pups, resulting in someone killing the dog out of spite? Was the pup blue? Is that why everyone wanted it? $10 says it was blue. Well played, everyone. Fix your god damned dogs and stop breeding.