If you want to find the posts that are actually reviews by the testers, go to "Today's Posts" or anywhere else where it says "Replies: XXXX", where X is a number. You can click on the number and a list will come up with everyone who has ever posted in the thread and how many posts they have in the thread. Click on the number by the tester's name and you will see all of their posts. Your idea is not stupid at all, but would be a nightmare for someone to do I would think. The only persons who could update the first post of a thread would be the first poster (who is usually JB in the review threads) or any of the moderators or admins. And I know I don't want to volunteer for this duty!