View Single Post
Old 08-29-2012, 10:09 AM   #33
Gymngatagaica

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
405
Senior Member
Default
That's more of an ideological statement than an observation of facts or a conclusion that can be reached from history.
Most casualties in the European theatre fell exactly when the opposing forces were capable, not when it was unbalanced as it was during the Blitzkrieg. But in the Soviet Union which had a capable military (they defeated the Nazis after all) the toll was staggering. And the Nazis were aware of the military capabilities of the Soviet Union but weren't deterred nevertheless. Japan wasn't deterred when it attacked Pearl Harbour nor Al Quaeda on 9/11. When the attacker for some reason believes they have a chance no military might forms a true deterrence.

Other than that, a strong military always needs a raison d'être. It's politically-fiscally untenable having a huge military that just sits on their asses all day. So the reasoning is that the mere presence of a huge military force enables war. And when one looks at all the nations that have such, not just the US, that's exactly what happens.
your version of history is interesting, not really based on facts but it is interesting.
here are facts
after ww1 the us, uk and france disarmed and russia imploded with their revolution.
Japan and Germany broke the treaties and increased the size of their military and modernized it(yes I know Japan did not fight with Germany during ww1)
so at teh start of ww2 you had the allied miltary that was filled with old equipment in disrepair vs a mordern miltary.
the russian miltary was in such bad shape many did not have guns or bullets. the only thing that kept them going was the supplies form the us and the size of the country.
Also the Japanese belived that the US where weak and had no will to fight and would just settle for peace giving up everything west of hawaii.
so historicaly speaking everythign you said was wrong. before ww2 the only countries with strong miltary was germany and japan the two countires that attacked the rest
Gymngatagaica is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:41 PM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity