You have made this argument before and it still doesn't hold any water. As I explained a while back people in the service industry almost entirely rely on tips as their hourly wage consists of a couple dollars at most. I made a little over $2 an hour when I worked two different waiter jobs in GA. If they are crap at their job, they get poor tips but here in the US if they are good at their job, they deserve to be compensated. I have absolutely no problem with people leaving little to no tip if the service was terrible but then you have people like Little_Lenny that "may not agree with the pay structure" but use that as an excuse to be a cheap ass. Sure you may not agree with the way payment is handled, I know I didn't at all when I offered great service and received very little tip from some but by not tipping or tipping very little, you aren't sticking it to the system but the server trying to make money. You could look at your argument from the exact opposite perspective as well why would a server go out of their way to give excellent service rather than passable service if they are receiving a flat rate?