DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Shaybani's Reliability in Narrating Hadith

**Ggskbpbz** · 02-18-2011, 09:52 PM

@ Muzamil husayn. Would u be kind enough to tell me about the hanafi view of Tareekh e Baghdad and Khateeb AL Baghdadi ra?

One think i have learnt is that these ignoramus fools have just one book which i think they refer to for all things hanafi related. Have you actually read the book? does the book not contain praise for Imam Abu Hanifah??? Is Khateeb al Bahdadi ra considered an authority on deen in the same way as Imam Abu Hanifah, Imam Malik, Imam Shafi, Imam Ahmed? So you prefer to take some of views from the book over everything and everyone else. (dont forget that Tareekh Baghdad isnt all negative about the imam).

Assalamu Alaikum

If my ears have searved me right then i heard Sheikh Yunus Jaunpuri state that the sohbat Ali Ibn al-Madīnī had with Imam Bukhari no other person had. The words of praise Imam Bukhari had for Ibn al-Madīnī he didnt have for anybody else.

It was apparent from his talk that Imam Bukhari held Ali Ibn al-Madīnī in the highest esteem, quite possibly more than anyone else the Imam Sahib had come in contact with. He also said i could not find that level of praise for anybody else in any of the books i have read that Imam Bukhari had for Ibn al-Madīnī.

You didnt answer that. So if Imam Bukhari praises Ali Ibn al Madini more than anyone else and Ali Ibn al Madini then praises Imam Shaybani, how is that not credible. You are talking about Imam Bukhari who is arguably the greatest muhaddith to have graced this earth, and his praise for someone doesnt count for anything?

02-18-2011, 09:52 PM	#16
Ggskbpbz Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 480 Senior Member	@ Muzamil husayn. Would u be kind enough to tell me about the hanafi view of Tareekh e Baghdad and Khateeb AL Baghdadi ra? One think i have learnt is that these ignoramus fools have just one book which i think they refer to for all things hanafi related. Have you actually read the book? does the book not contain praise for Imam Abu Hanifah??? Is Khateeb al Bahdadi ra considered an authority on deen in the same way as Imam Abu Hanifah, Imam Malik, Imam Shafi, Imam Ahmed? So you prefer to take some of views from the book over everything and everyone else. (dont forget that Tareekh Baghdad isnt all negative about the imam). Assalamu Alaikum If my ears have searved me right then i heard Sheikh Yunus Jaunpuri state that the sohbat Ali Ibn al-Madīnī had with Imam Bukhari no other person had. The words of praise Imam Bukhari had for Ibn al-Madīnī he didnt have for anybody else. It was apparent from his talk that Imam Bukhari held Ali Ibn al-Madīnī in the highest esteem, quite possibly more than anyone else the Imam Sahib had come in contact with. He also said i could not find that level of praise for anybody else in any of the books i have read that Imam Bukhari had for Ibn al-Madīnī. You didnt answer that. So if Imam Bukhari praises Ali Ibn al Madini more than anyone else and Ali Ibn al Madini then praises Imam Shaybani, how is that not credible. You are talking about Imam Bukhari who is arguably the greatest muhaddith to have graced this earth, and his praise for someone doesnt count for anything?
	Quote