DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Shaybani's Reliability in Narrating Hadith

**urbalatte** · 02-19-2011, 03:34 AM

Why would u mention a book whose author according to many Hanafis is mutashadid and has tasub against Hanafis? Indeed Tareekh e Baghdad has so many other biographies as well.When did i say that Khateeb Al Baghdad ra has only criticized Imam Abu hanifa? The criticism of Imam Abu hanifa ra in Tareekh e baghdad is spread on 54 pages ( refer to Masnad e Imam Abu hanfia page 48 ptinted by Maktaba e Rehmaniya) .
Mr A praised Mr C and Mr C then praised Mr X so this means that Mr A must be having positive thoughts or praise for Mr X? Common sense is far better than hizzbiya. Where do u put the criticism of all those great Muhaditheens regarding Mohamad Bin Hassan Al shaibani?
What do u mean by that highlighted portion of your post?

you forgot to mention that khateeb baghdadi also has 70 pages in praise of imam abu hanifa. What a convenient ommission.

Of course, your salafi friends didnt tell you that, did they?

http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&sou...q83J-izPo3l_Gw

Above is a response to many salafi lies about one of the greatest salaf ever to have lived, imam abu hanifa. He was a true salafi, not like you twits.

02-19-2011, 03:34 AM	#20
urbalatte Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 679 Senior Member	Why would u mention a book whose author according to many Hanafis is mutashadid and has tasub against Hanafis? Indeed Tareekh e Baghdad has so many other biographies as well.When did i say that Khateeb Al Baghdad ra has only criticized Imam Abu hanifa? The criticism of Imam Abu hanifa ra in Tareekh e baghdad is spread on 54 pages ( refer to Masnad e Imam Abu hanfia page 48 ptinted by Maktaba e Rehmaniya) . Mr A praised Mr C and Mr C then praised Mr X so this means that Mr A must be having positive thoughts or praise for Mr X? Common sense is far better than hizzbiya. Where do u put the criticism of all those great Muhaditheens regarding Mohamad Bin Hassan Al shaibani? What do u mean by that highlighted portion of your post? you forgot to mention that khateeb baghdadi also has 70 pages in praise of imam abu hanifa. What a convenient ommission. Of course, your salafi friends didnt tell you that, did they? http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&sou...q83J-izPo3l_Gw Above is a response to many salafi lies about one of the greatest salaf ever to have lived, imam abu hanifa. He was a true salafi, not like you twits.
	Quote