DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - barelvi and deobandi movements' views about islamic govt

**newspetty** · 06-22-2012, 01:21 PM

This whole paragraph needs several typo corrections. But I like it as such also. A plan is a boring document while a plane is a joy ride!

Can not listen to all of it but one point is a bit curious. He says the Salah does not stop from kufr. Beloved Rasoolallah (SAW) said that Salah stops you from Fawahish. Now kufr and Fawahish are not synonymous but Fawahish is indeed practical kufr. Inclination towards Hindus is quite apparent in the discussion.

It works till it is understandable. Some grammatically correct sentences stay just heap of words for this sinner as they are much hard to be conceived. Sometimes the analogies are far fetched and the personal preferences codified in such a tone that that despite their eloquence they stay incomprehensible for this dumb sinner.

The question posed infront of him is if it is permissible to pray behind Deobandis and Wahabis. (the words have become synonymous) and his response is as following.

1. Why don't you ask me if it is permissible to pray behind Atal Bihari Vajpai?
2. Atal Bihari Vajpai is better than the Wahabis.
3. And he is better because he has never questioned/insulted the knowledge of the Prophet PBUH.

06-22-2012, 01:21 PM	#4
newspetty Join Date Dec 2005 Posts 501 Senior Member	This whole paragraph needs several typo corrections. But I like it as such also. A plan is a boring document while a plane is a joy ride! Can not listen to all of it but one point is a bit curious. He says the Salah does not stop from kufr. Beloved Rasoolallah (SAW) said that Salah stops you from Fawahish. Now kufr and Fawahish are not synonymous but Fawahish is indeed practical kufr. Inclination towards Hindus is quite apparent in the discussion. It works till it is understandable. Some grammatically correct sentences stay just heap of words for this sinner as they are much hard to be conceived. Sometimes the analogies are far fetched and the personal preferences codified in such a tone that that despite their eloquence they stay incomprehensible for this dumb sinner. The question posed infront of him is if it is permissible to pray behind Deobandis and Wahabis. (the words have become synonymous) and his response is as following. 1. Why don't you ask me if it is permissible to pray behind Atal Bihari Vajpai? 2. Atal Bihari Vajpai is better than the Wahabis. 3. And he is better because he has never questioned/insulted the knowledge of the Prophet PBUH.
	Quote