DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Muslims prohibited from having Islamic states.

**EliteFranceska** · 06-24-2012, 06:50 PM

check this (http://www.3quarksdaily.com/3quarksd...-ali.html#more) and the comments if shariah ever makes it in pakistan, looks like the indians will go gung ho on pak, sad part, this piece is written by a liberal indian muslim, which is sad, indian and pak muslims should have the closest bond but now theres a nationalistic barrier may Allah remove this disease from us.

Sister I am absolutely unmotivated to read that article reason being that I too was just like that till some years ago.
My apologies and I repent from those beliefs and seek forgiveness of Allah (SWT) and I return to Him.
Apart from partition there was another mammoth tragedy that hit Indian Muslims in twentieth century and it was a mass transition to communist-Marxist ideology on part of Muslim intelligentsia. In no other language the socialist-communist movement was stronger than Urdu. So much so that intelligentsia, even now, is synonymous with the same group.
When I say Sunni Forumers Kindly Blog then on the back of my mind I have a desire that there be an alternative to the communist intelligentsia. Any way coming back to the article linked by you - I call these people Residual Communists. After we punctured the communist balloon in Afghanistan then it is no more chick to call yourself a Marxist. Now they have toned themselves down and usually are happy with the labels like secular and liberal. They are not that effective now as they used to be earlier but there presence is indeed there and if they catch you at the wrong foot they can bite viciously.

06-24-2012, 06:50 PM	#38
EliteFranceska Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 463 Senior Member	check this (http://www.3quarksdaily.com/3quarksd...-ali.html#more) and the comments if shariah ever makes it in pakistan, looks like the indians will go gung ho on pak, sad part, this piece is written by a liberal indian muslim, which is sad, indian and pak muslims should have the closest bond but now theres a nationalistic barrier may Allah remove this disease from us. Sister I am absolutely unmotivated to read that article reason being that I too was just like that till some years ago. My apologies and I repent from those beliefs and seek forgiveness of Allah (SWT) and I return to Him. Apart from partition there was another mammoth tragedy that hit Indian Muslims in twentieth century and it was a mass transition to communist-Marxist ideology on part of Muslim intelligentsia. In no other language the socialist-communist movement was stronger than Urdu. So much so that intelligentsia, even now, is synonymous with the same group. When I say Sunni Forumers Kindly Blog then on the back of my mind I have a desire that there be an alternative to the communist intelligentsia. Any way coming back to the article linked by you - I call these people Residual Communists. After we punctured the communist balloon in Afghanistan then it is no more chick to call yourself a Marxist. Now they have toned themselves down and usually are happy with the labels like secular and liberal. They are not that effective now as they used to be earlier but there presence is indeed there and if they catch you at the wrong foot they can bite viciously.
	Quote