DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Qasr or Outwardly Combining (Hanafi Madhab)

**CHEAPPoem** · 06-27-2012, 03:26 AM

Thats what im trying to get at. It doesn't say he prayed Qasr, which means he prayed the full prayer. If he would have prayed Qasr, that definitely would have been mentioned in the narrations, thats not something that a narrator would just leave out.

That's an assumption, and not a valid one at that. Why is it impossible for the narrator to miss it out? Afterall, the point of the narration is regarding time, not type of salah. Don't forget that many narrations are narrated 'by meaning' i.e. the wording is changed, or extracted from larger ahadith by later narrators.

06-27-2012, 03:26 AM	#7
CHEAPPoem Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 564 Senior Member	Thats what im trying to get at. It doesn't say he prayed Qasr, which means he prayed the full prayer. If he would have prayed Qasr, that definitely would have been mentioned in the narrations, thats not something that a narrator would just leave out. That's an assumption, and not a valid one at that. Why is it impossible for the narrator to miss it out? Afterall, the point of the narration is regarding time, not type of salah. Don't forget that many narrations are narrated 'by meaning' i.e. the wording is changed, or extracted from larger ahadith by later narrators.
	Quote