DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Qasr or Outwardly Combining (Hanafi Madhab)

**CHEAPPoem** · 06-27-2012, 03:51 AM

So you think the Prophet prayed qasr, even though its not mentioned in both of the ahadeeth I gave? Wouldn't that be an assumption?
When something isn't mentioned in a hadeeth, isn't it safe to assume it didn't happen?

It is not mentioned that the Messenger performed qasr or a normal salah. Instead, only the time/name of the salah is mentioned. It is an assumption to assume anything about the nature of the salah, other than the time/name. You're reading ahadith as if they're passages from a book of fiqh. . .

06-27-2012, 03:51 AM	#9
CHEAPPoem Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 564 Senior Member	So you think the Prophet prayed qasr, even though its not mentioned in both of the ahadeeth I gave? Wouldn't that be an assumption? When something isn't mentioned in a hadeeth, isn't it safe to assume it didn't happen? It is not mentioned that the Messenger performed qasr or a normal salah. Instead, only the time/name of the salah is mentioned. It is an assumption to assume anything about the nature of the salah, other than the time/name. You're reading ahadith as if they're passages from a book of fiqh. . .
	Quote