Thread
:
What is Zakir Naik's views on Tablighi Jamaat?
View Single Post
05-15-2012, 02:38 PM
#
9
wJswn5l3
Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
396
Senior Member
Can you summarize what he's saying here?
I have not gone 4 months, so I don't know urdu
Firstly it was the woman who asked the ques.
Q: what is your opinion on a new sect now days in india called TJ that leaves his home for 40days and read a Useless book called Fazaile Amaal which contins false ahdith ( the words used is Jhooti Hadith ) etc. ?
A: Fazaile- amal consist of mixture of saheeh hadith , weak hadith , fabircation and stories , we should take from sahih hadiths , like Bukhari , tirnidhi , ibn majah .
and i have comes around any hadith that says to go for 40days for TJ and this things is not proven from Quran or Hadith.
I have translated only the half part.
Note: i find the woman more agreessive than zakir naik , the tone she used was very harsh as for zakir naik he is only good in comparative religion and that too in some aspects of it rest i consider him worth no to listen.
Because he is not a scholar , nor alim , hafiz or anything he has just memorise some verses of Holy Quran from here and there for his talks. so what else will you expect from him. To me a Scholar is 1st and Last choice.
Quote
wJswn5l3
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by wJswn5l3
All times are GMT +1. The time now is
03:47 PM
.