DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - help required answering a salafi, and combating salafi resources

**qzgCVHex** · 06-19-2012, 11:44 PM

did imam nawawi hold the oppinion that you can force your daughter to marry someone she doesnt want to marry?

So because I said that IF the shaafi madhab says you can force women into marriage the the shaafi madhab is wrong, taht means i dont want unity with people? Thats stupid bro

the shafi madhab does say that marriage can be forced under some conditions. i criticized your (and your brethren's) arrogance and your illusion that you can go about disproving (or proving right) rulings of a madhab based on your and your brethren's (uneducated) approach towards deriving fiqh from Qur'an and Sunnah.
this is also very intolerant, for a layman.
as for unity. would you unite with a shia who comes and abuses the ummahat ul momineen and then says ok im done, lets unite. im not comparing you with a shia it is just that an ideology based on extremist intolerance cannot be accepted by those approached for unity. if a hanafi goes to a shafi'i and says we should get united despite our differences, there won't be any rejection. yet many hanafi rulings collide with shafi'i rulings.

the problem is with you. the muqallids are all united. you consider us blind followers, pass racist remarks for the people in indo-pak, think we consider the ulema infallible and you have the audacity to ask for unity? when was the last time you saw a muqallid fighting with a muqallid of another madhab on this forum? on the rare occasion that has happened it was resolved peacefully in a short time.

if you are honest about unity learn one fiqh in its entirety and become muqallid of it. this will wash away your uneducated intolerance. and allow your mind to accept muqallids can also be right and most of the time they are right.

May Allah bless you too.

06-19-2012, 11:44 PM	#39
qzgCVHex Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 467 Senior Member	did imam nawawi hold the oppinion that you can force your daughter to marry someone she doesnt want to marry? So because I said that IF the shaafi madhab says you can force women into marriage the the shaafi madhab is wrong, taht means i dont want unity with people? Thats stupid bro the shafi madhab does say that marriage can be forced under some conditions. i criticized your (and your brethren's) arrogance and your illusion that you can go about disproving (or proving right) rulings of a madhab based on your and your brethren's (uneducated) approach towards deriving fiqh from Qur'an and Sunnah. this is also very intolerant, for a layman. as for unity. would you unite with a shia who comes and abuses the ummahat ul momineen and then says ok im done, lets unite. im not comparing you with a shia it is just that an ideology based on extremist intolerance cannot be accepted by those approached for unity. if a hanafi goes to a shafi'i and says we should get united despite our differences, there won't be any rejection. yet many hanafi rulings collide with shafi'i rulings. the problem is with you. the muqallids are all united. you consider us blind followers, pass racist remarks for the people in indo-pak, think we consider the ulema infallible and you have the audacity to ask for unity? when was the last time you saw a muqallid fighting with a muqallid of another madhab on this forum? on the rare occasion that has happened it was resolved peacefully in a short time. if you are honest about unity learn one fiqh in its entirety and become muqallid of it. this will wash away your uneducated intolerance. and allow your mind to accept muqallids can also be right and most of the time they are right. May Allah bless you too.
	Quote