DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - help required answering a salafi, and combating salafi resources

**ffdfriendforurr** · 06-20-2012, 12:31 AM

What made me ask u a question? Read what u said, that's what made me ask the question, can u give me the quote to MY queston (not your above question). Also, in my 1st comment i gave u a quote so that we can stick to the topic.

As for your above reply i know About GF Haddad, i purchased his transalation of ibn jahbal R

Ok, so here's the background information.

I was saying: Many Ash'aris say that Atharis (By which I mean Imam Ahmad's aqeedah as explained by all the Hanbalis from Abu Bakr al-Khallal to Ibn Taymiyyah) are anthropomorphists and I gave the example of GF Haddad by referring to his 'tirades,' which has a meaning like criticisms, of the above-mentioned aqeedah.

You then said: 'have you got quotes for the above,' which I took to mean that: you wanted quotes to prove that GF Haddad has written tirades against the Hanbali aqeedah.

I said: 'Read anything he's ever written on the subject,' meaning, the subject of Ibn Taymiyyah.

Then you said the above.

As I said, just read his biography of Ibn Taymiyyah. He just barely stops short of takfir.

06-20-2012, 12:31 AM	#40
ffdfriendforurr Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 517 Senior Member	What made me ask u a question? Read what u said, that's what made me ask the question, can u give me the quote to MY queston (not your above question). Also, in my 1st comment i gave u a quote so that we can stick to the topic. As for your above reply i know About GF Haddad, i purchased his transalation of ibn jahbal R Ok, so here's the background information. I was saying: Many Ash'aris say that Atharis (By which I mean Imam Ahmad's aqeedah as explained by all the Hanbalis from Abu Bakr al-Khallal to Ibn Taymiyyah) are anthropomorphists and I gave the example of GF Haddad by referring to his 'tirades,' which has a meaning like criticisms, of the above-mentioned aqeedah. You then said: 'have you got quotes for the above,' which I took to mean that: you wanted quotes to prove that GF Haddad has written tirades against the Hanbali aqeedah. I said: 'Read anything he's ever written on the subject,' meaning, the subject of Ibn Taymiyyah. Then you said the above. As I said, just read his biography of Ibn Taymiyyah. He just barely stops short of takfir.
	Quote