DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**pavilionnotebook** · 06-30-2010, 04:12 PM

With regards to those comments...the 3 points that the indian muslims do not need pakistan's help. Also that terrorism is 1 way.i.e from pakistan and also his viewpoint the majority of hindus respect muslims. I think he put the figure at 70% or maybe 90% can't remember exactly but it was a very high figure. All these facts are clearly in his response to Musharraf. As aapa you are familiar with the madani family please clarify these issues. Once the father of maulana mahmood mentioned something infront of my father and my father clarified it with him (Hadhrat Maulana Asad madni rh). If I mention it here it would cause a storm....however the fact is that it seems indian muslims are using some sort of diplomacy...and at times making ambigous statements so as not to alienate the majority hindu population.

I could clarify things with him if you gave me some video/audio link where you heard these comments. There are so many people on the internet who throw rumours around about the Madani family that it would be embarrassing to just say 'one person on the internet said you said this but cannot back his statement up'. The Madani family right from the time of Moulana Hussain Ahmad Madani and his ustaadhs before him have been involved in Indian politics for one reason and that is for the social, economic and religious welfare of the Muslims in India. They stand up for them when no one else can. Understandably, when you get involved in such issues people will make all sorts of false attributions and put all sorts of words in your mouth and the easiest way to do that is to cause rifts amongst the Muslims themselves and then focus hard on the seeds of disunity until the little, insignificant things cancel out all the good. Every political leader will make mistakes. The difference of opinion between the akabireen at the time of the Indian partition is no secret, but the hearts of the akabireen are full of respect and love for each other.

Anyway, if you can please provide links to these statements I would be grateful.

Otherwise, with all due respect, I would trust my own instinct and say I cannot believe the statements are 100% accurate.

06-30-2010, 04:12 PM	#25
pavilionnotebook Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 527 Senior Member	With regards to those comments...the 3 points that the indian muslims do not need pakistan's help. Also that terrorism is 1 way.i.e from pakistan and also his viewpoint the majority of hindus respect muslims. I think he put the figure at 70% or maybe 90% can't remember exactly but it was a very high figure. All these facts are clearly in his response to Musharraf. As aapa you are familiar with the madani family please clarify these issues. Once the father of maulana mahmood mentioned something infront of my father and my father clarified it with him (Hadhrat Maulana Asad madni rh). If I mention it here it would cause a storm....however the fact is that it seems indian muslims are using some sort of diplomacy...and at times making ambigous statements so as not to alienate the majority hindu population. I could clarify things with him if you gave me some video/audio link where you heard these comments. There are so many people on the internet who throw rumours around about the Madani family that it would be embarrassing to just say 'one person on the internet said you said this but cannot back his statement up'. The Madani family right from the time of Moulana Hussain Ahmad Madani and his ustaadhs before him have been involved in Indian politics for one reason and that is for the social, economic and religious welfare of the Muslims in India. They stand up for them when no one else can. Understandably, when you get involved in such issues people will make all sorts of false attributions and put all sorts of words in your mouth and the easiest way to do that is to cause rifts amongst the Muslims themselves and then focus hard on the seeds of disunity until the little, insignificant things cancel out all the good. Every political leader will make mistakes. The difference of opinion between the akabireen at the time of the Indian partition is no secret, but the hearts of the akabireen are full of respect and love for each other. Anyway, if you can please provide links to these statements I would be grateful. Otherwise, with all due respect, I would trust my own instinct and say I cannot believe the statements are 100% accurate.
	Quote