DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**pavilionnotebook** · 07-01-2010, 02:38 PM

Brother London786,

There is a difference of aasmaan zameen in what Moulana actually said and what you translated his comments to be. Small differences that change the meaning completely.

Put it this way: If a Shia, or other deviated person came to your house and tried to give you advice on how to do the tarbiyah of your children what would you say? Something like 'Thanks but no thanks. I can sort the problem of my own children out and I don't need your help. You go worry about your own kids.' This is the same thing. The words are not to be taken literally.

Which is why, with regards to the rest, I understand what you are saying. But at the time of the Gujrat massacres, there was no-one from the Muslim community, who was able to stop the brutal actions of the Hindus. The Muslims were weak and a minority. This vulnerability was the problem.

I'll leave it to that. You might want to respond to the words of Borther akabirofdeoband, because he raises some very interesting points far more worthy of discussion.

07-01-2010, 02:38 PM	#36
pavilionnotebook Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 527 Senior Member	Brother London786, There is a difference of aasmaan zameen in what Moulana actually said and what you translated his comments to be. Small differences that change the meaning completely. Put it this way: If a Shia, or other deviated person came to your house and tried to give you advice on how to do the tarbiyah of your children what would you say? Something like 'Thanks but no thanks. I can sort the problem of my own children out and I don't need your help. You go worry about your own kids.' This is the same thing. The words are not to be taken literally. Which is why, with regards to the rest, I understand what you are saying. But at the time of the Gujrat massacres, there was no-one from the Muslim community, who was able to stop the brutal actions of the Hindus. The Muslims were weak and a minority. This vulnerability was the problem. I'll leave it to that. You might want to respond to the words of Borther akabirofdeoband, because he raises some very interesting points far more worthy of discussion.
	Quote