DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**MexicoCity** · 06-11-2012, 01:33 PM

No. Self cleaning is obligatory and Bayt is merely Mustahab.

Some times to draw attention to contemporary contingencies Masha-ikh over emphasize some points. It is like in a small community people going about their own business but in times of emergence everybody is diverted to a single task like building a band for protection against flood or fetching water to extinguish a blazing fire.

I agree with the bolded part, but hazrat don't issue statements like 'In the fitnah filled modern times it is obligatory to have a Shaikh.'

Yes we are a generation of people who say 'its just a sunnah' contrary to how the Sahaba treated the sunnah. But one cannot present it as a different matter just to catch attention. Mustahab is Mustahab and Fardh is Fardh.

06-11-2012, 01:33 PM	#17
MexicoCity Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 566 Senior Member	No. Self cleaning is obligatory and Bayt is merely Mustahab. Some times to draw attention to contemporary contingencies Masha-ikh over emphasize some points. It is like in a small community people going about their own business but in times of emergence everybody is diverted to a single task like building a band for protection against flood or fetching water to extinguish a blazing fire. I agree with the bolded part, but hazrat don't issue statements like 'In the fitnah filled modern times it is obligatory* to have a Shaikh.'* Yes we are a generation of people who say 'its just a sunnah' contrary to how the Sahaba treated the sunnah. But one cannot present it as a different matter just to catch attention. Mustahab is Mustahab and Fardh is Fardh.
	Quote