[paypaltoegold1]

Assalamualikum,

I happen to hear differing stories from these two great scholars regarding the "Green Dome of the Prophet"

While Pir Zulfikar d.b credits "Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi r.e.h" for saving it from demolition at the hands of the Salafi movement, Maulana Tariq Jameel in his speech creditted Maulaba Shafi Uthmani d.b. for the same.

Are they speaking of two different incidents or there is a conflict in their claims ?

Genuine and serious question.

1. There wasn't always a dome there
2. It wasn't even green till a few hundred years ago

So whats up with saving it? I don't understand it, is there a religious obligation?

And I am NOT calling for its destruction, either! Discussion on colour...