DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Mufti Ebrahim Desai Saheb (Damat Barakatuhum) on Tabligh Jamaat

**paypaltoegold1** · 06-11-2012, 09:40 PM

correct.

If i was given elaan responsibility in TJ (i.e, the annoucement thats given after jamaat salah in the masjid by TJs that such and such a talk will take place) i'll say it as this:

"Our success in this world and the world hereafter lays in following the commands of Allah through the way shown by Nabi (saw). To get this into our lives requires effort, regarding one of these efforts and one of the ways in practicing one of these efforts, inshalllah an important talk will take place after the remaining salah/duas. All brothers are requested to participant, inshallah it'll be very beneficial"

Rather than the one thats always said:

"Our success in this world and the world hereafter lays in following the commands of Allah through the way shown by Nabi (saw). To get this into our lives requires effort, regarding this effort, inshalllah an important talk will take place after the remaining salah/duas. All brothers are requested to participant, inshallah it'll be very beneficial"

Your additional Eilaan is neither correct nor conducive nor beneficial because when as a laymen your job is to follow Allah (SWT), Sayyidina Rasul-ullah

and those in Authority over you.

You have gone in the Jamaat so its NOW your Islamic obligation to follow the Ameer and his methodology and not insert your own (thinking into it).
People are used to listening to Eilaan in a specific way so no point in confusing masses because in 5 seconds you don’t have the time to clarify what you are saying.
Your aim should be to encourage MAXIMUM PARTICPIATION in Aa’maal and not to start a Ijtehaadi discussion.

In person or online we can discuss the merits and shortcomings of Tableeh (as we do) but when in Jamaat obey the Ameer (Implicitly and explicitly) and thats Waajib upon you.

06-11-2012, 09:40 PM	#11
paypaltoegold1 Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 519 Senior Member	correct. If i was given elaan responsibility in TJ (i.e, the annoucement thats given after jamaat salah in the masjid by TJs that such and such a talk will take place) i'll say it as this: "Our success in this world and the world hereafter lays in following the commands of Allah through the way shown by Nabi (saw). To get this into our lives requires effort, regarding one of these efforts and one of the ways in practicing one of these efforts, inshalllah an important talk will take place after the remaining salah/duas. All brothers are requested to participant, inshallah it'll be very beneficial" Rather than the one thats always said: "Our success in this world and the world hereafter lays in following the commands of Allah through the way shown by Nabi (saw). To get this into our lives requires effort, regarding this effort, inshalllah an important talk will take place after the remaining salah/duas. All brothers are requested to participant, inshallah it'll be very beneficial" Your additional Eilaan is neither correct nor conducive nor beneficial because when as a laymen your job is to follow Allah (SWT), Sayyidina Rasul-ullah and those in Authority over you. You have gone in the Jamaat so its NOW your Islamic obligation to follow the Ameer and his methodology and not insert your own (thinking into it). People are used to listening to Eilaan in a specific way so no point in confusing masses because in 5 seconds you don’t have the time to clarify what you are saying. Your aim should be to encourage MAXIMUM PARTICPIATION in Aa’maal and not to start a Ijtehaadi discussion. In person or online we can discuss the merits and shortcomings of Tableeh (as we do) but when in Jamaat obey the Ameer (Implicitly and explicitly) and thats Waajib upon you.
	Quote