DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The Future Of Islam In India, Pakistan & Bangladesh By Sheikh Imran Hosein

**StanWatts** · 06-11-2012, 12:41 AM

Yeah you najdi's on this forum ...

NO rebelion against the syrian govt...

When Hussain (ra) went against Yazeed you hypcrytes said Husaain ra was wrong because he rebelled against the khaliphate/ govt.

why dont you apply the same rule to syrian armed oppositions...

You munafiq's have no shame left in you.....

What are you on about?

Let us assume you're argument actually holds any wait (in reality, it doesn't, because Bashar is not a shar'i Imam, no bay'ah was taken from him, and his secularism and nusayrism puts some serious question marks on his Iman). . .

You guys are equally guilty of hypocrisy. If you believe in rebellion against a non-shar'i Imam such as what Imam al-Husayn did to Yazid, why don't you support the Syrians? Just because you believe the wahhabis are hypocrites, why do you have to be one too? Why can't you support both? You should go back to high school and learn about the fallacy of False Dilemma.

Before you start spewing emotional rhetoric, consider your own position.

By the way, I support the rebellions of Imam al-Husayn, Imam Zayd, Imam an-Nafs az-Zakiyyah and the rest.

06-11-2012, 12:41 AM	#11
StanWatts Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 418 Senior Member	Yeah you najdi's on this forum ... NO rebelion against the syrian govt... When Hussain (ra) went against Yazeed you hypcrytes said Husaain ra was wrong because he rebelled against the khaliphate/ govt. why dont you apply the same rule to syrian armed oppositions... You munafiq's have no shame left in you..... What are you on about? Let us assume you're argument actually holds any wait (in reality, it doesn't, because Bashar is not a shar'i Imam, no bay'ah was taken from him, and his secularism and nusayrism puts some serious question marks on his Iman). . . You guys are equally guilty of hypocrisy. If you believe in rebellion against a non-shar'i Imam such as what Imam al-Husayn did to Yazid, why don't you support the Syrians? Just because you believe the wahhabis are hypocrites, why do you have to be one too? Why can't you support both? You should go back to high school and learn about the fallacy of False Dilemma. Before you start spewing emotional rhetoric, consider your own position. By the way, I support the rebellions of Imam al-Husayn, Imam Zayd, Imam an-Nafs az-Zakiyyah and the rest.
	Quote