DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**cenRealliat** · 06-07-2012, 02:10 PM

So masha'Allah we have yet another mujtahid and do-it-yourself Mufti who is able to extract the 'illas of the hukum just by reading some translations of ahadith!
Even though Ulama gave different opinion and they mention the hadith (iirc) in which is said that to wear garments below ankles is in itself riya...

I dont know I agree with him. I just dont like that he comes across or tries to come across as a scholar at the begining where he states I & a few scholars from the west.
However his view is a valid view in shariah & we should entertain it. its not the clothing & the way it fits that is haraam but the kibr that it brings about or projects. & this is also the view of many traditional ulama of the past. Allahu ya'lam.

06-07-2012, 02:10 PM	#19
cenRealliat Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 520 Senior Member	So masha'Allah we have yet another mujtahid and do-it-yourself Mufti who is able to extract the 'illas of the hukum just by reading some translations of ahadith! Even though Ulama gave different opinion and they mention the hadith (iirc) in which is said that to wear garments below ankles is in itself riya... I dont know I agree with him. I just dont like that he comes across or tries to come across as a scholar at the begining where he states I & a few scholars from the west. However his view is a valid view in shariah & we should entertain it. its not the clothing & the way it fits that is haraam but the kibr that it brings about or projects. & this is also the view of many traditional ulama of the past. Allahu ya'lam.
	Quote