I dont know I agree with him. I just dont like that he comes across or tries to come across as a scholar at the begining where he states I & a few scholars from the west. However his view is a valid view in shariah & we should entertain it. its not the clothing & the way it fits that is haraam but the kibr that it brings about or projects. & this is also the view of many traditional ulama of the past. Allahu ya'lam.