DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**RichardFG435** · 06-09-2012, 01:25 AM

With all due respect, this backward mindset which sadly some sunnis have is unfortunate. (not all, just some)
Islam encourages discussions as it encourages the mind to learn new and more things.
No knowledge is bad and thats a fact.
I was merely advising the jafari view on this position.
If you can discuss the other views such as hanafi, shafee, hanbali and maliki, why not the jafari view point?
It is only a discussion, as i am hoping through discussion, both sides can learn about eachother, instead of choosing to end a discussion merely because one doesnt belong to your school of thought.
It baffles me.... Do you treat others such as christians like this aswell? Or just muslims itself?
Remember what the quran teaches us, to be one ummah.
I understand there are different groups, but our mindset should still be united as one.
Its only by doing this we are abiding by the laws of the quran.
Salaam

The problem is "ja'fari fiqh" is only in shi'as' heads, it never originated from Imam Ja'far Al-Sadiq (

) so I was just pointing the fact your post is useless on a sunni forum. So for us you're propagating something opposite to Islam and I would reply the same to a Christian who would try to pass his views as a mainstream islamic view.
I agree we should be united, but question is who is included in "we" ?

Really I say all this without any disrespect intended to your person. We just don't have the same basis so what benefit do we gain from each other ?

Wassalamu 'alaykum.

06-09-2012, 01:25 AM	#38
RichardFG435 Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 424 Senior Member	With all due respect, this backward mindset which sadly some sunnis have is unfortunate. (not all, just some) Islam encourages discussions as it encourages the mind to learn new and more things. No knowledge is bad and thats a fact. I was merely advising the jafari view on this position. If you can discuss the other views such as hanafi, shafee, hanbali and maliki, why not the jafari view point? It is only a discussion, as i am hoping through discussion, both sides can learn about eachother, instead of choosing to end a discussion merely because one doesnt belong to your school of thought. It baffles me.... Do you treat others such as christians like this aswell? Or just muslims itself? Remember what the quran teaches us, to be one ummah. I understand there are different groups, but our mindset should still be united as one. Its only by doing this we are abiding by the laws of the quran. Salaam The problem is "ja'fari fiqh" is only in shi'as' heads, it never originated from Imam Ja'far Al-Sadiq () so I was just pointing the fact your post is useless on a sunni forum. So for us you're propagating something opposite to Islam and I would reply the same to a Christian who would try to pass his views as a mainstream islamic view. I agree we should be united, but question is who is included in "we" ? Really I say all this without any disrespect intended to your person. We just don't have the same basis so what benefit do we gain from each other ? Wassalamu 'alaykum.
	Quote