[sirmzereigMix]

Salaam Aleikum

Even if this is true then who said the Shi'ah represent the Ahlul Bayt? Wow funny logic. ?

We are mere lovers of the ahlul bayt who try to obey the prophet command of following the quran and ahlul bayt after him.... Its in sahih muslim aswell, so how can it not be true to your own standards?

So as usual him and those who follow his opinion declare that they prove what Allah proves and deny what Allah denies. So when Allah says this does he mean physical hands? I think you just summarised the way of thinking of the salafie school of thought with regards to:
-The literal reading of the quran
- and the attributes of allah swt.


This is the danger when a layperson interprets the quran without guidance from the ahlul bayt.

Please do not mock! A famous hadith from one of our imams says for us not to mock sunni beliefs. THe reason for this the same reason we schouldnt mock other religions. Because if we mock them they in return may mock one of our religious leaders or even Allah Swt.

If i have offended anyone directly please forgive me. Naturally some people may be upset with me just being a shia , but thats something that i cant controle. Or they may be upset with a discussion. In the end we both need to have respect for another and discuss a topic without silly lines such as your leader is this or your leader would be doing this. Its unislamic for an islamic forum.

Explaining the Sunni creed, Shaykh al-Islam said:“They (Ahlus Sunnah) love the people of the household of the Messenger of Allah; they regard them with love and loyalty, and they heed the command of the Messenger of Allah concerning them…but they reject the way of the (Shia) Rafidhis who hate the Sahabah and slander them, and they reject the way of the Nasibis who insult Ahlel Bayt in words and deed.” (Ibn Taymiyyah, Majmoo al-Fatawa, 3/154) Than whats your opinion of the destruction of the shrine in jannatul baqi? Your answer here obviously will show the enmity some have towards ahlul bayt. No matter how you will try to justify it. I rather think education is far better then destroying islamic history. Also to have that view that shias slander and hate sahaba is outrageous and again only fueling lies and division in the islamic ummah, and this is coming from the top of the salafie school of thought.

Actions speak louder than words. You only have to look at Jannatul Baqi, and the answer lies, who the real haters are.

Salaam