DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Very detailed questions about Zakah on Land

**FelikTen** · 12-05-2011, 12:39 PM

Now for Zakat payable for Point C(Building being built, construction not finished, No money exchanged.)

If the your contract with the builder is as I mentioned above, Point C is same as Point B, you are pretty much the owner of 100% of the land.
But here is where hope1's quote could be applied:

What is fasid bro?

From my understanding the whole arrangement is fasid. Cannot be undertaken. If it is already undertaken then Beheshti provides solution:

The rule with regard to ijârah fâsidah is that whatever had been agreed upon will not be given. Instead, he will be given whatever
payment is normally made for a particular job. If it is a house, the tenant will have to pay the normal rental. However, if the normal
payment or the normal rental is more than what had been agreed upon, then the normal payment or rental will not be given. Instead, he
will be paid that which was agreed upon. In short, he will be entitled to receive the amount which is less. even though paying the builders may not look like ijarah it is ijarah. In fiqh ijarah refers to both renting and hiring.

12-05-2011, 12:39 PM	#19
FelikTen Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 441 Senior Member	Now for Zakat payable for Point C(Building being built, construction not finished, No money exchanged.) If the your contract with the builder is as I mentioned above, Point C is same as Point B, you are pretty much the owner of 100% of the land. But here is where hope1's quote could be applied: What is fasid bro? From my understanding the whole arrangement is fasid. Cannot be undertaken. If it is already undertaken then Beheshti provides solution: The rule with regard to ijârah fâsidah is that whatever had been agreed upon will not be given. Instead, he will be given whatever payment is normally made for a particular job. If it is a house, the tenant will have to pay the normal rental. However, if the normal payment or the normal rental is more than what had been agreed upon, then the normal payment or rental will not be given. Instead, he will be paid that which was agreed upon. In short, he will be entitled to receive the amount which is less. even though paying the builders may not look like ijarah it is ijarah. In fiqh ijarah refers to both renting and hiring.
	Quote