DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Grapappytek** · 06-07-2012, 04:39 AM

So didn't Lal Masjid pass a fatwa that the one who helps US against mujahideen will not have be prayed over in the same way a bandit is not prayed over? If so, does this mean they did not believe in their takfeer whilst believing what they did was haraam?

It seems they just made a comparison, but the reason for those helping US against Mujahiding not being prayed over is due to their action being kufr.
While the bandits are not prayed over to show how disliked such action is.
Then they made a link in form of a comparison "as it happens for..".
While in the first case it is kufr..

Allah knows best, I'm not a scholar by any chance..

06-07-2012, 04:39 AM	#8
Grapappytek Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 395 Senior Member	So didn't Lal Masjid pass a fatwa that the one who helps US against mujahideen will not have be prayed over in the same way a bandit is not prayed over? If so, does this mean they did not believe in their takfeer whilst believing what they did was haraam? It seems they just made a comparison, but the reason for those helping US against Mujahiding not being prayed over is due to their action being kufr. While the bandits are not prayed over to show how disliked such action is. Then they made a link in form of a comparison "as it happens for..". While in the first case it is kufr.. Allah knows best, I'm not a scholar by any chance..
	Quote