Doing without the apologetic fatawa of the "neo-traditionalists" around "seekers guidance" and their selective quoting of Islamic Fiqh, Allah in the Qur'an dictates the conditions after which one may resort to a not-harmful physical punishment. This second "another opinion" is whose? That of modern liberal people? Which scholar ever used the modern relativistic slogan of "only Allah is to judge", when Allah himself ordered for the apostates to be killed? Actually, the penalty for homosexual acts is capital punishment. Under an Islamic government, obviously.