DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**BuyCheapest** · 05-27-2012, 10:53 AM

Generally speaking I have no problem with Sunni forum, I enjoy having conversations with a lot of the brothers here and love them for the sake of Allah. However, I really dislike the bias that is shown, even though subtle.

I have nothing to hide nor lie about, and if anyone asks me concerning the Deoband/Hanafis/Maturidis I will tell them exactly how I feel, and for the most part I appreciate a lot tthat the Deoband do and believe in, I have no problem as well with the Hanafi Madhab, but I guess you can say my biggest conflict is with the Aqeedah portion of the Maturidi way, however, I have never considered them to be outside of Ahlul Sunnah, even if I disagree with some points that they have.

My blog, has NOTHING in regards to dispraising anyone of those three groups above, I guess the only thing that maybe disliked in it, is the quote I posted from the Ashari book concerning the Quran being created, however, outside of that I can't really see the problem with my blog. And even that post, asked Allah to forgive him, and I can say for sure it's not out of context.

It was said my blog is too "Salafi" but what exactly is the meaning of Salafi here? I follow a Madhab, I also respect and follow the scholars of Saudi in regards to the Madhab, I also quote and respect the scholars of the Hanbali Madhab in regards to Aqeedah and Fiqh, So I'm asking sincerely what is the problem with my blog that forces the Mods to delete links to it?

If the Hanbali Aqeedah version of Ibn Qudaama, Ibn Rajab, Etc etc... is not allowed on Sunni forums, just say that so we know where we stand. If you consider Tafweedh 50% not to be part of Ahl Sunnah, say that so we know where we stand, however if you deem "Salafi, Wahhabis" to be from Ahlul Sunnah, there is no room for bias, rather there is only room for having a sincere open opinion and debate, your bias is fine for you to keep in certain circumstances, however if you name your website "Sunni" it should incorporate all things SUNNI.

Do any of the other Hanbali forum members feel a Bias on these forums, or even if you're not Hanbali but not really following a Madhab, do you feel at all like you are outcast?

Also I'd like to get to know the Hanbalis a little more if you read this, can you introduce yourselves?

May Allah reward you All.

I would not call it a hardcore bias but there is a certain trend of unacceptability. The major problem with the deobandi approach is that they have a happy picture of the four madhabs. Mostly they are under the impression that the four madhabs are on the same page and they Imams have just disagreed in a few fiqh related issues. They concept propagated is that all the four are Ahli sunnah wal jamaat and the Salafis are the strangers in the town. It takes a good amount of time for them to realize that Salfis are an tributary of the Hanbalis and they Hanbalis have differed in Aqeedah from the Ashartites and maturidis through out the history. It takes a further good amount of time to absorb this fact. The usual reaction is "They have ruined the madhab of Imam Ahmad and now folks like Abu Ja'ffar Al Hanbali are going to resurrect the real Hanbali madhab".

05-27-2012, 10:53 AM	#5
BuyCheapest Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 625 Senior Member	Generally speaking I have no problem with Sunni forum, I enjoy having conversations with a lot of the brothers here and love them for the sake of Allah. However, I really dislike the bias that is shown, even though subtle. I have nothing to hide nor lie about, and if anyone asks me concerning the Deoband/Hanafis/Maturidis I will tell them exactly how I feel, and for the most part I appreciate a lot tthat the Deoband do and believe in, I have no problem as well with the Hanafi Madhab, but I guess you can say my biggest conflict is with the Aqeedah portion of the Maturidi way, however, I have never considered them to be outside of Ahlul Sunnah, even if I disagree with some points that they have. My blog, has NOTHING in regards to dispraising anyone of those three groups above, I guess the only thing that maybe disliked in it, is the quote I posted from the Ashari book concerning the Quran being created, however, outside of that I can't really see the problem with my blog. And even that post, asked Allah to forgive him, and I can say for sure it's not out of context. It was said my blog is too "Salafi" but what exactly is the meaning of Salafi here? I follow a Madhab, I also respect and follow the scholars of Saudi in regards to the Madhab, I also quote and respect the scholars of the Hanbali Madhab in regards to Aqeedah and Fiqh, So I'm asking sincerely what is the problem with my blog that forces the Mods to delete links to it? If the Hanbali Aqeedah version of Ibn Qudaama, Ibn Rajab, Etc etc... is not allowed on Sunni forums, just say that so we know where we stand. If you consider Tafweedh 50% not to be part of Ahl Sunnah, say that so we know where we stand, however if you deem "Salafi, Wahhabis" to be from Ahlul Sunnah, there is no room for bias, rather there is only room for having a sincere open opinion and debate, your bias is fine for you to keep in certain circumstances, however if you name your website "Sunni" it should incorporate all things SUNNI. Do any of the other Hanbali forum members feel a Bias on these forums, or even if you're not Hanbali but not really following a Madhab, do you feel at all like you are outcast? Also I'd like to get to know the Hanbalis a little more if you read this, can you introduce yourselves? May Allah reward you All. I would not call it a hardcore bias but there is a certain trend of unacceptability. The major problem with the deobandi approach is that they have a happy picture of the four madhabs. Mostly they are under the impression that the four madhabs are on the same page and they Imams have just disagreed in a few fiqh related issues. They concept propagated is that all the four are Ahli sunnah wal jamaat and the Salafis are the strangers in the town. It takes a good amount of time for them to realize that Salfis are an tributary of the Hanbalis and they Hanbalis have differed in Aqeedah from the Ashartites and maturidis through out the history. It takes a further good amount of time to absorb this fact. The usual reaction is "They have ruined the madhab of Imam Ahmad and now folks like Abu Ja'ffar Al Hanbali are going to resurrect the real Hanbali madhab".
	Quote