DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**justashonglefan** · 05-17-2012, 02:03 AM

Sunni Student,

It doesn't matter about Hizb Tahrir or not. What matters is communicating and understanding a fellow Muslim brother.

Agreed. My entire reason for writing what I wrote was to make it easier to understand what the brother was communicating because it appears that at least one person, if not more, were confused about what his point was.

It is outright hizbiya- haram sectarianism, partisanship- to simply dismiss someone or render him a pariah because you think he is from a certain group.

I neither dismissed him nor rendered him a pariah. Reread what I wrote and see if it is reasonable to conclude either of those things on the basis of what I wrote.

And last I heard, HT are Muslim brothers, period. So what is this about if Caliph likes HT, or listens to them, etc.?

....

What it is "about" is making clear where he probably stands so that others can understand his perspective rather than being confused about it and having conversations that go nowhere.

05-17-2012, 02:03 AM	#25
justashonglefan Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 382 Senior Member	Sunni Student, It doesn't matter about Hizb Tahrir or not. What matters is communicating and understanding a fellow Muslim brother. Agreed. My entire reason for writing what I wrote was to make it easier to understand what the brother was communicating because it appears that at least one person, if not more, were confused about what his point was. It is outright hizbiya- haram sectarianism, partisanship- to simply dismiss someone or render him a pariah because you think he is from a certain group. I neither dismissed him nor rendered him a pariah. Reread what I wrote and see if it is reasonable to conclude either of those things on the basis of what I wrote. And last I heard, HT are Muslim brothers, period. So what is this about if Caliph likes HT, or listens to them, etc.? .... What it is "about" is making clear where he probably stands so that others can understand his perspective rather than being confused about it and having conversations that go nowhere.
	Quote